Tax obligations are a part of life in the UK, whether someone is an employee, landlord, self-employed contractor, or company director. While some individuals manage their own tax returns confidently, others find the process complex, stressful, and time-consuming. Knowing when to file taxes independently and when to hire a professional tax accountant is not only a matter of convenience but also of financial accuracy, compliance, and peace of mind.
This guide offers a detailed exploration of both options. It helps UK taxpayers understand which situations allow for a do-it-yourself approach and when seeking expert help is the smarter, safer, and more cost-effective decision.
1. Understanding Tax Responsibilities in the UK
The UK tax system requires individuals to report income, gains, and reliefs accurately while meeting deadlines and retaining proper records. The most common taxes that require attention include:
-
Income Tax
-
National Insurance Contributions (NICs)
-
Capital Gains Tax (CGT)
-
Dividend Tax
-
Inheritance Tax (IHT)
-
Corporation Tax (for company owners)
The Self Assessment tax return system is designed to allow individuals to calculate and report their own taxes online. However, misinterpretation of tax rules, incorrect entries, or missed deadlines can trigger penalties and HMRC enquiries.
2. When You Can Confidently DIY Your Taxes
There are many cases where taxpayers can manage their own tax returns without needing professional help. These tend to be straightforward financial situations with minimal sources of income and few reliefs or deductions to claim.
You Can Likely DIY Your Taxes If:
a) You’re an Employee with a Single Income Source
Employees paid through PAYE (Pay As You Earn) typically do not need to file a tax return unless they have additional income. Tax is automatically deducted from wages, making it simple to manage.
b) You Have Savings Interest and Dividends Below Allowances
If income from savings or dividends falls within the Personal Savings Allowance (£1,000 for basic-rate taxpayers) or Dividend Allowance (£500 for 2024/25), there may be no need for a tax return.
c) You Only Earn Small Self-Employed or Side-Income
Individuals earning less than £1,000 from self-employment or property can use the Trading Allowance or Property Allowance. No tax return is required within this threshold.
d) You Rent a Room Under the Rent-a-Room Scheme
Earnings under £7,500 from renting a furnished room in a main residence are tax-free and generally do not require complex reporting.
e) You Claim Simple Work-Related Expenses
Claiming fixed-rate deductions for uniforms, tools, or mileage does not typically require expert guidance.
3. Advantages of Doing Taxes Yourself
-
Cost-free aside from time investment
-
Full control over personal financial information
-
Understanding of personal finances improves
-
No need to share sensitive documents with third parties
HMRC’s online systems are designed to be user-friendly and guide individuals through the filing process. With access to payslips, bank statements, and P60 or P45 forms, many can complete their tax return in a matter of hours.
4. When Hiring a Professional Tax Accountant Is the Better Choice
While DIY taxes work for basic financial circumstances, many people experience life events or business changes that increase tax complexity. In these cases, expert assistance helps avoid errors, minimise tax liability, and ensure compliance.
You Should Consider Hiring a Professional If:
a) You’re Self-Employed with Significant Profits
Freelancers, consultants, tradespeople, and contractors with high income or growing businesses can benefit from expert tax planning, expense optimisation, and accurate bookkeeping.
b) You’re a Landlord
Owning one or multiple rental properties introduces complexities such as mortgage interest relief, allowable expenses, and Capital Gains Tax on sales.
c) You Have Foreign Income or Work Abroad
Income from overseas employment, pensions, investments, or property must be declared under the UK tax system. Double Taxation Agreements and remittance basis rules can complicate filing.
d) You Have Capital Gains from Selling Assets
Shares, second homes, investment properties, and cryptocurrency profits may all trigger CGT. Calculating costs, gains, and allowable deductions can be confusing without guidance.
e) You Run a Limited Company or Partnership
Directors and shareholders encounter Corporation Tax, dividend planning, salary structure, and National Insurance considerations.
f) Your Income Exceeds £100,000
At this level, the Personal Allowance tapers and pension contributions, charitable donations, or salary structuring could restore allowances or reduce tax liabilities.
g) You’re Facing an HMRC Enquiry or Penalty
A professional can correspond with HMRC on your behalf, manage disputes, and ensure accurate records are provided.
5. Benefits of Hiring a Tax Accountant
a) Accuracy and Compliance
Professional accountants ensure all figures are correct and that returns meet HMRC standards. This reduces the risk of penalties from inaccurate reporting.
b) Tax Efficiency
Accountants know where allowances, reliefs, and deductions apply. They can suggest legal strategies for saving tax, such as pension contributions or income splitting.
c) Time-Saving
For business owners, landlords, and busy professionals, outsourcing tax affairs frees time to focus on work, family, or business growth.
d) Peace of Mind
Knowing that a qualified expert has reviewed and submitted tax information reduces stress and helps avoid errors.
6. How to Choose a Professional Tax Accountant
Not all accountants offer the same level of service. Choosing a qualified, experienced tax specialist ensures accurate advice and peace of mind.
Checklist for Selecting an Accountant:
-
Qualifications: Look for members of ACCA, ICAEW, or CTA.
-
Experience: Specialisation in personal tax, self-employed accounts, or property taxation.
-
Transparent Fees: Clear pricing without hidden costs.
-
Responsiveness: Ability to answer questions promptly and clearly.
-
Reputation: Verified reviews, client testimonials, or word-of-mouth recommendations.
7. Costs of Hiring an Accountant vs Potential Savings
The cost of employing an accountant varies depending on the complexity of the tax situation. For a standard Self Assessment tax return, fees might range from £150 to £350. More complex returns involving rental income, share sales, or business accounts may cost more.
However, these fees are often outweighed by the tax saved through professional planning. Accountants can identify reliefs and expenses that individuals might overlook, potentially saving hundreds or even thousands of pounds.
8. Common Mistakes People Make When Filing Taxes Without Help
-
Missing deadlines leading to automatic penalties.
-
Failing to report additional income from property, investments, or overseas sources.
-
Incorrectly claiming expenses, especially for home offices, vehicles, or travel.
-
Ignoring Capital Gains Tax on crypto assets or shares.
-
Not keeping proper financial records.
Such errors can trigger HMRC investigations, interest charges, and fines.
9. Hybrid Approach — DIY with Professional Review
Some individuals choose a middle-ground solution: completing most of their tax return themselves but hiring a professional to review the final draft before submission. This ensures accuracy while keeping costs lower than full-service tax preparation.
This option is especially useful for first-time landlords, freelancers, or company directors who want to learn the process while avoiding major mistakes.
10. The Role of Technology in Modern Tax Management
Online accounting software such as QuickBooks, Xero, and FreeAgent has made it easier to manage income and expenses. These tools help taxpayers:
-
Track invoices, receipts, and bank transactions.
-
Calculate tax liabilities automatically.
-
Prepare for Making Tax Digital (MTD) requirements.
-
Share data securely with an accountant if needed.
Even with these tools, the interpretation of tax law and long-term planning often still requires professional insight.
11. When It’s Essential to Get Help — No Compromise
In certain situations, professional support is not optional but essential. These include:
-
Receiving an official HMRC investigation or audit.
-
Receiving inheritance or managing someone else’s estate.
-
Divorce or separation involving property and assets.
-
Buying or selling a business.
-
Complex share schemes, trusts, or offshore assets.
In these cases, mistakes can be costly and may have long-lasting legal or financial consequences.
12. Building a Long-Term Relationship with a Tax Adviser
For growing businesses, landlords with expanding portfolios, or high-net-worth individuals, building an ongoing relationship with a tax adviser ensures consistent planning.
A good accountant helps with:
-
Annual tax returns.
-
Quarterly financial reviews.
-
Business structure decisions.
-
Retirement planning and exit strategies.
-
Inheritance Tax and estate planning.
One trusted provider, My Tax Accountant, offers personal tax services, Self Assessment support, and strategic planning to individuals across the UK through their platform.
Conclusion
Knowing when to handle taxes independently and when to seek professional help can make a significant difference to financial outcomes. Simple financial situations often allow for a DIY approach, especially for employees with single incomes or individuals with small side earnings. However, when income sources multiply, assets grow, or HMRC compliance becomes uncertain, hiring a professional tax accountant is the safer and more strategic choice.
Tax is not simply about compliance; it is about planning, protecting, and preserving income. Whether doing it alone or with expert guidance, understanding the limits of both approaches allows every taxpayer to make informed, confident decisions.
